blockchain development
tailor-made development
digital marketing
Learn from Web3
contact

LEARN ABOUT BLOCKCHAIN AND WEB3 FOR FREE

MiCA vs MiFID II: which regulation applies to your token

Quick answer: the line between MiCA and MiFID II comes down to a single question: does the token embed a financial instrument? If it represents a share, a bond, a fund unit or a derivative, it falls under MiFID II (Directive 2014/65/EU) and, in Spain, under Ley 6/2023 (Spain's Securities Markets Law, LMVSI); MiCA is excluded. If it is not a financial instrument, it falls within the scope of MiCA, as an asset-referenced token (ART), an e-money token (EMT) or another crypto-asset (MiCA, Regulation (EU) 2023/1114, Art. 2(4)).

The question that decides the regime

Before looking at the technology, look at the law. MiCA and MiFID II do not overlap: they divide the field according to the legal nature of the token. MiCA governs crypto-assets that are not financial instruments; MiFID II governs financial instruments, whether or not they are represented on a blockchain. MiCA itself says so explicitly: it does not apply to crypto-assets that qualify as financial instruments (Regulation (EU) 2023/1114, Art. 2(4)).

The most common mistake is asking whether a token complies with MiCA before establishing which right it represents. If the token confers a right to dividends, to interest, to a fund unit or to a position in a derivative, it is a financial instrument, and MiCA is not its rulebook. It falls under MiFID II (Directive 2014/65/EU, Annex I, Section C).

Decision tree

  • Step 1. Does the token embed a right typical of a financial instrument (a share, a bond, a collective investment scheme unit, an Annex I derivative under MiFID II)? If yes, it is a security token: it falls under MiFID II and the LMVSI; where it is represented through DLT/blockchain, it needs an ERIR (the entity responsible for the registration and recording of DLT-based securities) to keep its register (Ley 6/2023, BOE-A-2023-7053). MiCA does not apply.
  • Step 2. If it is not a financial instrument, is it referenced to one or more official currencies? It is an e-money token (EMT), governed by Title IV of MiCA and supervised by the Banco de España.
  • Step 3. Is it referenced to a basket of assets, currencies or commodities in order to keep a stable value? It is an asset-referenced token (ART), Title III of MiCA.
  • Step 4. Is it none of the above but still a crypto-asset, for example a utility token? It falls within MiCA's general regime for other crypto-assets (Title II), with a white paper obligation and CNMV supervision.
  • Step 5. Is it a genuinely unique, non-fungible asset (a true NFT)? It sits outside MiCA, unless in practice it behaves as a fungible series or disguises a financial instrument (Regulation (EU) 2023/1114).

If, after working through this, the classification is still unclear, you are in a grey area: a legal analysis before issuance is advisable, because substance prevails over form (Art. 4 MiFID II).

MiCA and MiFID II, side by side

MiFID II and LMVSI (security tokens)

  • What it governs: financial instruments (shares, bonds, fund units, derivatives), including when they are tokenised.
  • The rules: MiFID II (Directive 2014/65/EU) and, in Spain, Ley 6/2023 (LMVSI). Prospectus under the Prospectus Regulation (EU) 2017/1129.
  • On-chain registration: through an ERIR; the trading infrastructure may rely on the DLT Pilot Regime (Regulation (EU) 2022/858).
  • Authority: CNMV.

MiCA (crypto-assets that are not financial instruments)

  • What it governs: EMTs, ARTs and other crypto-assets, including utility tokens.
  • The rules: MiCA (Regulation (EU) 2023/1114), applicable to EMTs and ARTs from 30 June 2024 and to the rest from 30 December 2024.
  • The document: a crypto-asset white paper, not a securities prospectus.
  • Authority: CNMV, and the Banco de España for EMTs and ARTs.

Worked examples

  • Token over a company's shares: a financial instrument, so MiFID II and the LMVSI apply, with an ERIR. MiCA excluded.
  • Tokenised EUR 50M five-year bond: a debt security, so MiFID II and the Prospectus Regulation apply. MiCA excluded.
  • Tokenised fund units: a financial instrument (a collective investment scheme), so MiFID II and CIS rules apply. MiCA excluded.
  • Euro-referenced stablecoin: an EMT, so Title IV of MiCA and the Banco de España apply.
  • Service-access token (utility): another crypto-asset, so Title II of MiCA applies, with a white paper.

Common mistakes

  • Believing MiCA governs security tokens. It does not: it excludes them expressly (Art. 2(4)).
  • Classifying by the type of blockchain rather than by the right the token embeds.
  • Assuming that tokenising avoids prospectus or authorisation obligations. Tokenisation changes the medium, not the nature of the asset.
  • Treating as a utility a token that in fact confers economic rights. The CNMV looks at substance.

What this means for you

Classification drives both cost and regulatory path: a prospectus and an ERIR if it is a security; a MiCA white paper if it is a crypto-asset; an additional authorisation if services are also provided. Settling this before you design the token avoids reworking the structure later.

Frequently asked questions

Is a security token governed by MiCA or by MiFID II?

By MiFID II and, in Spain, by the LMVSI. MiCA excludes financial instruments (Regulation (EU) 2023/1114, Art. 2(4)).

What is the ERIR and when is it needed?

It is the entity responsible for the registration and recording of securities tokenised through DLT. Any issuance of blockchain-represented securities in Spain needs one (Ley 6/2023).

Is MiCA already in force?

Yes. The EMT and ART rules apply from 30 June 2024 and the rest from 30 December 2024, with a transitional regime for crypto-asset service providers (CASPs).

Is a stablecoin the same as a security token?

No. A currency-referenced stablecoin is an EMT under MiCA; a security token is a financial instrument under MiFID II.

This content is for general information and educational purposes only. It is not legal, tax or investment advice and does not replace consultation with a qualified professional. Regulation on tokenisation and crypto-assets evolves; always check the version in force of the rules cited in the BOE (boe.es) and EUR-Lex (eur-lex.europa.eu).

Unknown Gravity

About the author

High-performance consulting specialized in Blockchain. Experts in tokenization.

Services
·
Services
·
Services
·
Services
·

Services

·
Services
·
Services
·
Services
·
Services
DEVELOPMENT‍
‍WEB3 AND WEB2
Anyone can assemble lines of code.
‍
‍We go further.

‍With meticulous planning, carefully crafted design, and user-centered development, we explore the complexity of human behavior to bring to life solutions that truly connect.

Use technology to grow in the digital environment of your company in a secure way.

Development
‍blockchain

• NFTs & PoAPs COLLECTIONS
• CRYPTOCURRENCIES AND TOKENS
• REAL WORLD ASSETS (RWA)
• TOKENOMICS & WhitePapers
• TAILOR-MADE SMART CONTRACTS
• SMART CONTRACT AUDITS
• DECENTRALIZED APPLICATIONS (DApps)
• CRYPTOCURRENCY PAYMENT GATEWAYS
• TOKENIZATION
• PUBLIC AND PRIVATE BLOCKCHAIN

SPECIALIZED IN TAILOR-MADE SOLUTIONS.

CONSULTANCY

We are a team specialized in creating projects and launching them to success!

content creation, ANALYTICS and social networks

Through cutting-edge tools and insightful analysis, we transform data into powerful insights.

With our experience, you will gain a deep understanding of your audience, allowing you to make better decisions and enhance your impact on social networks.

In the art of Content Creation, we design strategies that enhance your digital presence with relevant and engaging content, ensuring a genuine connection with your audience.

CREATIVITY AND DESIGN

We bring to life exceptional and emotionally immersive visual experiences that not only capture glances, but also generate meaningful dialogue.

From compelling images to interactive campaigns, we infuse innovation and style into every creative aspect, creating content that not only looks impressive, but also connects deeply with your audience.
DIGITAL MARKETING & design
In a saturated market, where everyone can launch campaigns and strategies, we stand out.

With a strategic vision, a design thought out in detail and an execution focused on the consumer, we explore the complexities of human behavior to give life to campaigns that go beyond the conventional, connecting in a genuine way with the emotions and aspirations of our target audience.

It's not just about selling, but about creating experiences that last in memory and generate a lasting connection with our audience.
From Spain to the World
·
From Spain to the World
·
From Spain to the World
·
From Spain to the World
·
From Spain to the World
·
From Spain to the World
·
From Spain to the World
·
From Spain to the World
·
From Spain to the World
·
From Spain to the World
·
From Spain to the World
·
From Spain to the World
·
From Spain to the World
·
From Spain to the World
Calle peatonal con farolas alineadas y edificios clásicos a ambos lados, con una torre blanca al fondo.

HEADQUARTERS

C. Marqués de Larios, 4
29005 - Malaga

Cuatro personas sentadas en sillas de mimbre en un patio con paredes de ladrillo y una hamaca.

LABS

C. La Gitanilla, 17
29004 - Malaga

INNOVATION LEADERS
Contact us

WE WILL HELP YOU

Request a free consultation to learn about our solutions

Your information is submitted succesfully!

We will contact you via the email you provided in the form.

Oops! Something went wrong while sending the message.

Contact us

WE WILL HELP YOU
Request a free consultation to learn about our solutions
Your information is submitted succesfully!
We will get in touch with you through the email you provided in the form.
Oops! Something went wrong while sending the message.

PARTNERS

THEY TALK ABOUT US

Blockchain as a Service (BaaS)

NFT Consulting

Data tokenization

Digital Assets

Tokenization of precious metals

Tokenization of financial assets

Development of tokenization platforms

Tokenization of energy and renewable assets

Tokenized Emissions Management Software

ERIR platform for token registration and control

Blockchain consulting for companies

Development of smart contracts

Tokenization of real estate

Whitepapers

Tokenomics

Issuance of tokens

Crypto Payment Gateway

Real World Assets (RWA)

DApp Development: Decentralized Applications

Asset tokenization

Private blockchains

White label tokenization platform

Product traceability

DeFi protocols

Blockchain consulting for companies

Create NFT collections

Texto estilizado que dice 'UNKNOWN. gravity' en blanco sobre fondo negro.

951 23 15 26 - info@unknowngravity.com

LinkedIn
Twitter
Instagram
PRESS
blog
LinkedIn
Twitter
Instagram
Sello de certificación en forma de bandera naranja con el logo de Enisa y texto que dice: Certificada como empresa emergente, Ministerio de Industria y Turismo.
UNKNOWN GRAVITY SL ha recibido una subvención de la Consejería de Empleo, Empresa y Trabajo Autónomo de la Junta de Andalucía, financiada por la Unión Europea con cargo al Programa FSE+ Andalucía 2021-2027, para la inserción laboral y el fomento de la contratación en el ámbito de la Comunidad Autónoma de Andalucía. Programa Emplea-T Línea 2. Incentivo a la segunda o sucesivas contrataciones indefinidas ordinarias por parte de personas trabajadoras autónomas, y a cualquier contratación indefinida ordinaria por parte de Pymes.
Powered by Unknown Gravity - SINCE 2023
Cookies
Legal